Writing about real people can
be dangerous. Writing about the mob can get you a pair of cement shoes. But
writing about your best friend can buy you a lawsuit.
This post isn’t meant to
discourage anyone from writing about real people. But the responsible writer
will weigh both the benefits and the risks and take steps to minimize the
latter.
So what can you do to avoid a
lawsuit? Unless you are the Godfather of movie fame, there is no foolproof way
to keep people from suing you. There are a number of things you can do to make
it less likely, however, and I’ll talk about them November and December. But
first you need to know what defamation is.
Generally speaking, defamation
is 1) a false statement 2) about an identifiable person 3) that is communicated
to others and 4) harms the person’s reputation. If it is written or recorded in
a tangible medium, such as a book or a television news tape or a Facebook post,
it is libel. If it is merely spoken, such as a comment made at a party, it is
slander. Libel usually reaches a larger audience than slander does, and putting
the statement in writing or some other tangible medium also increases the
chances that it will reappear, so libel usually gets a larger damage award from
the jury. Other than that, there are no significant legal differences between
the two. Libel and slander are both defamation.
So what are the legal
requirements for defamation?
1. A False Statement
First, the statement must be
false. Truth and falsity aren’t always what they seem, however. You can defame
someone by using real facts that carry a false implication. “Uncle Charlie
sleeps around a lot” may be literally true if he takes frequent overnight
business trips, but that isn’t what people will think you mean.
In a defamation lawsuit, the
judge or jury decides how an average reader or listener would interpret what was
written or said. If they decide that a reasonable person wouldn’t give the
words a defamatory meaning, then it is not defamation. Remember, however, that
it is the reader/listener’s interpretation, and not the writer/speaker’s
intended meaning, that counts.
2. About an
Identifiable Person
A statement is not defamatory
unless it refers to a recognizable individual, business, or other entity. So
are you safe if you change the names to protect the guilty? No. Changing a
person’s name isn’t enough if readers can still recognize the person from the
description.
3. That is Communicated
to Others
The statement must be
communicated to someone other than the person it refers to. If you write
something negative about your mother in your diary and she is the only one who
sees it, it isn’t libel.
4. And Harms the
Person’s Reputation
Finally, the statement must
harm the person’s reputation. If it refers to something trivial or is clearly
an opinion, it’s not defamatory. “She can’t even boil water” is trivial—unless
the subject makes her living as a cook. But even if she is a professional chef,
the reader or hearer probably understands the words as pure opinion. Either
way, the statement does not harm the person’s reputation.
So what if the person’s
reputation is so bad that you can’t possibly make it worse? Then you’ve found
your perfect victim—theoretically. However, few people have a reputation that
bad. One appellate court even found that a convicted criminal known to engage
in violent behavior might conceivably be harmed by being called a hitman or a
pimp.
Now you know what defamation
is, how can you limit your liability?
The answer depends on what you
write. Next month, I’ll cover fiction.
__________
Kathryn Page Camp is a
licensed attorney and full-time writer. Writers
in Wonderland: Keeping Your Words Legal was a Kirkus’ Indie Books of the Month Selection for April 2014. The
second edition of Kathryn’s first book, In
God We Trust: How the Supreme Court’s First Amendment Decisions Affect
Organized Religion, was released
on September 30, 2015. You can learn more about Kathryn at www.kathrynpagecamp.com.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your astute advice, Kathryn! You've no doubt saved several writers' hides today.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment, Rachael. I'm always amazed when writers use real people--even by name sometimes--in their fiction and don't think twice about it.
ReplyDelete