



The most saintly of us competitors fall back on praying for our judges--if not for their salvation, certainly for their walk with God. Obviously, they don't know Him very well, or they would recognize the superior talents with which He gifted us.
I never quite reached that plateau of generosity. Usually, upon scanning scores, I threw my manuscript into a drawer until I had undergone my official detox process. It consisted of swearing off writing forever; throwing a few books; pounding a few pillows; and eating a few bags of chocolate while crying more than a few tears.
Eventually, I did look on the bright side. Checking out the judge's publishing credentials, I told myself, "Well, if she/he can get published, anyone can."
One year, however, properly prepared with books to throw, pillows to pound, and bags of chocolate to snarf, I stared at my scores and received a phone call: I had finaled. Instead of detoxing, I celebrated--and even more when at conference I won my category.
The following year, however, I discovered that past Genesis winners were strongly encouraged to serve as judges.
Me? A judge?
I thought of the scripture, "In the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you."
I heard God laughing.
Since then, I have judged the Genesis several times, and I know other authors who have wedged critiquing manuscripts between sorting socks, working a day job, baking birthday cakes, visiting in-laws, surviving root canals, soothing angry spouses, attending kids' plays (three times), shopping for prom dresses, spending time with amorous spouses, starting potty training, attending traffic court classes--and somewhere in there, too, she/he probably is trying to write a book or two or three. Or edit a few dozen.
No, Genesis judges aren't perfect. A few sadistic egomaniacs no doubt have sneaked into our ranks, as they do in every profession, organization, or ministry. Sometimes, when called upon to judge, we say "yes" mostly because we're really bad at saying "no." Still, many of us judge the Genesis because although we, too, cringe at receiving critiques, we know we would not have progressed this far without them. In other words: we care.
Are we perfect? No. (God's laughing even harder.)
Please feel free to pray for our walk with Him. And pray that with His help, we'll do the best job possible.
Thanks!
Ruth: I'm having the time of my life working for Love Inspired Books. My most recent release was the 4 Star Yuletide Hearts, part of the Men of Allegany County series, and I'm looking forward to A Family to Cherish, my July release. I was blessed to final and/or win in the Noble Theme, later called Genesis, multiple times. I love this contest. It allows Christian authors a chance to shine in their genre, and that's rare. I contracted my first agent as a result and caught the interest of several editors, exactly what I wanted to accomplish.
The Genesis/Noble Theme was good to me and for me. I began to see the broad scope of Christian fiction, how its growth has opened up doors of opportunity for so many. It was worth every penny I spent and got me lots of great feedback even when I didn't win. I also made sure I entered several different entries, hoping to shine multiple times. And it worked!
Cheryl:Winning Genesis significantly affected my career. My now-editor, from my dream house, Love Inspired, was sitting in the front row. She was very excited and remembered me from another manuscript I had submitted. I sold my first book to them days after returning from the conference...it had won the Romance Category of Noble Theme the year prior. Now, I'm on my 10th book...in a medical mini-series titled Eagle Point Emergency. The Doctor's Devotion is on sale for pre-order now. Doctor to the Rescue will be available in December.
Even the years I'd entered and not finaled were beneficial because the judges' comments steered me to things I needed to work on craft-wise. It also helped me see my strengths. The positive reinforcement gave me courage to keep trying even though I didn't score high the first couple times I entered. That I started out with very low scores then progressed to win and to contract is a testament that this contest has far-reaching benefits.
I think in the beginning, most writers aren't as far along as they think they are. I see a lot of open hostility from people who don't final. When you complain openly, you're making yourself look unprofessional. That always bothers me because they don't realize that agents and editors are watching. As one editor wisely put it: the industry has a looooooong memory. Stay humble, teachable, Christ-like and determined to learn. Judges aren't right 100% of the time. But they are right MOST of the time.
Camy: The editor who would later buy Deadly Intent, my first Love Inspired Suspense, was the first person to congratulate me after I won in 2005. Getting the attention of editors and agents was the most surprising aspect. I had been unaware of the growing prestige of the contest and hadn't thought that the editors who hadn't judged the contest would pay that much attention to the winners. Now that Genesis has gained so much respect among the Christian publishing industry, I think current winners can be assured that their names are being noted by editors, especially when the finalists have appointments with them at the ACFW conference.
It's hard to put your "baby" out there and I applaud participants for it! Go into it with a humble heart because even the most critical comment could have a grain of truth in it that will help you improve your writing. I have gained the absolute best feedback from my judges, even the ones who gave me low scores. It kept me constantly striving to improve my craft and hit the audience I want to write for. My most current book is Protection for Hire published by Zondervan.
Congratulations to the winners. Continue to improve your craft. Editors and agents will be watching, so show them you're hard-working, humble, and kind. Also show that you're generous with your time in giving back to the Genesis—offer to judge next year!
Thanks, ladies. These authors had more to say. Complete transcripts are available when you request by comment below. For the list of winners from other years or for more about the contest, go to www.acfw.com.
![]() |
Crystal, out wrestling alligators, my easy job |
2011 Indiana Chapter Genesis Semi-Finalists: Carole Brown, Melanie Brasher (Joy N. Malik,) Sarah Ladd |
You’d really like to attend a writer’s conference to get feedback on your wip, but you can’t afford the time or the cash. There’s an easier and less-costly solution. Get your manuscript evaluated by entering the GENESIS contest for $35 per entry or the FRASIER contest for $30 per entry.
Below are ten top reasons to enter:
Deadline for the GENESIS is March 4th and the FRASIER is March 31st. There’s time to enter both.
Click below for contest guidelines:
http://www.mybooktherapy.com/index2.php/the-frasier-contest/
How many of you have entered in the past or will enter this year? What were your experiences?